Cookies from Luxembourg
Anyone who immediately thinks of sweet treats when they hear the word “cookies” has probably not spent much time dealing with the little trackers of our digital daily lives. Yet they are currently on everyone’s lips, as the European Court of Justice published a new directive on October 1, 2019. It stipulates that the setting of cookies that are not strictly necessary requires the active consent of users.
But what are non-essential cookies?
Cookies are text information stored in the browser as soon as a website is visited. When the website is visited again, the information is read, the visitor is identified, and login data, the online retailer’s shopping cart, or language selection are saved. These are referred to as technical cookies (session cookies), which are necessary and useful. In addition, however, there are those cookies that enable the creation of profiles based on the surfing behavior of users. These are the so-called tracking cookies or third-party cookies, which are precisely not necessary. The user is tracked beyond a single website. Special tracking services are required for this. These are usually third-party companies that collect and evaluate data and link it to the user’s name. Scripts are integrated into websites (images, banners, pixels, fonts) which set cookies after the respective page is visited. The operator of an online shop can then, for example, display advertising tailored to the customer or adapt their offer.
Previously, users could only block unwanted tracking cookies via security settings in the browser (e.g., block all and allow desired ones or vice versa, allow all and put unwanted ones on a blacklist). However, active action to suppress cookies presupposes that the user is aware of the crumbs they leave behind for resourceful data refineries. This is likely one of the reasons behind the ECJ ruling of October 1. Since then, users may no longer be left in the dark: cookies may only be set after the user’s active consent.
The decision of the European Court of Justice
The basis for the new European Court of Justice directive was a competition by the company Planet49, which was organized purely for advertising purposes. The participation form was provided with checkboxes with a pre-selected checkmark. Participants agreed (neither actively nor voluntarily) that a web analysis service could be used. This involves setting cookies that result in the evaluation of surfing and usage behavior. For the European Court of Justice, this is a violation of privacy. The counter-argument that cookies only involve pseudonymized and not personal data was not accepted by the ECJ, as it involves information that makes it possible to identify the user (e.g., by assignment to an identifier such as a name, an identification number, location data, or an online identifier).
Art. 2 of Directive 95/46 states:
For the purposes of this Directive, ‘the data subject’s consent’ shall mean any freely given specific and informed indication of his wishes by which the data subject signifies his agreement to personal data relating to him being processed.
In any case, the privacy of users must be protected, even if it is not always clearly a matter of collecting personal data. Devices and the data stored on them are part of the users’ privacy. If devices are accessed using spyware, web bugs, hidden identifiers, or similar without their knowledge, this is considered a violation of privacy.
As a result, cookies may only be stored and tracking services used if the user actively consents. Furthermore, in the future, information must be provided if cookie data is passed on to third parties. Silence, pre-selected boxes, or inactivity do not constitute consent.
This directive seems to be a logical measure for the protection of users and also shows the direction the ePrivacy Regulation will take. Nonetheless, one can criticize that there is no binding catalog of permitted and prohibited cookies, and not a word was lost on the scale of penalties for non-compliance. We will see how many website operators implement the requirements and whether we users will now be bombarded with even more banners (which we simply click away). It certainly remains exciting!
